Case law
Possible defence against prejudiced expert witnesses
The Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) previously ruled that if the tax administration doubts the nature of activities for claiming an allowance for research and development, it should obtain an expert’s opinion. In the court’s view, only an expert…
SAC: VAT not a part of immovable property acquisition tax base
The Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) in its recent judgement surprisingly diverged from the explanatory report on the Senate’s Statutory Measure on the Tax on Acquisition of Immovable Property. According to the report, the agreed-upon price for…
SAC: Partial payment orders may not be issued
According to the Supreme Administrative Court, the Tax Procedure Rules do not allow the issuance of a payment order for only a portion of tax. This means that VAT payers from whom the tax administrators retain excess deductions sometimes amounting…
Misuse of company credit card ruled legitimate reason for terminating employment
The Supreme Court recently dealt with a case involving the controversial use of a business payment card. The employer believed that the employee had misused the card and immediately terminated the employment. The employee objected that he had not…
Meeting conditions for exempted delivery
Proving the entitlement for VAT exemption when delivering goods to another member state is becoming increasingly difficult due to the growing demands of the tax administrators. Taxpayers will thus surely be happy to hear of any ruling that may make…
Liability for VAT in payments to foreign accounts contrary to EU law
A supply recipient’s liability for unpaid VAT if the payment for the supply is made by a transfer to a foreign account is contrary to EU law, according to a regional court’s recent decision (file No. 22 Af 102/2014).
Full damage compensation in car accidents
The Constitutional Court again ruled on compensation of damage in car accidents. After a series of rulings dealing with the amortisation of spare parts used to repair crashed cars, the court now looked into the issue of compensation for damage…
Supreme Court: end of zero tolerance to alcohol at work
Although the Labour Code bans employees from entering the workplace under the influence of alcohol, the Supreme Court in its recent judgment stated that not every breach of this duty is automatically a justified reason for dismissal. According to…
Stricter conditions for tax deductibility of expenses?
Some rulings by the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) have surprising outcomes and de facto narrow the space for recognising expenses as tax-deductible by requiring proof that that a service was received from a specific supplier.
Interest on long-retained excess deductions liable to income tax?
Interest on long-retained excess deductions of up to 14% p.a. was first awarded to a taxable entity by the Supreme Administrative Court more than two and a half years ago. Since then, a number of administrative courts proceeded similarly and…
Defence against unlawful procedure to remove doubt may be well worth it
In its recent judgement, the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) emphasised that the procedure to remove doubt should only serve to clarify concrete uncertainties. It is a tool to ascertain or to check, immediately and without delay, whether a tax…
Duty to identify clients and ascertain beneficial owners
According to the ruling of the Municipal Court in Prague, it is not possible to simply identify a statutory body, director or other top manager as the beneficial owner in cases of unclear ownership structures, as such persons may not be in a direct…