Case law

EU General Court: business gifted in two equal shares falls outside VAT transfer…

The transfer of a business free of charge to two individuals, each receiving a half share, does not constitute a transfer of a totality of assets or part thereof under Article 19 of the VAT Directive if neither share allows its recipient to carry on…

EU General Court: boat repairs in EU need not incur duty or import VAT

Where goods from a third country are brought into the EU solely for repair and then returned without being used there, import VAT may not arise and any customs debt may be extinguished. The EU General Court confirmed this in a judgment addressing…

CJEU: abuse of law not limited to conduit companies

A parent company’s genuine economic activity and beneficial ownership of income do not, in themselves, preclude application of the abuse of law doctrine. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) confirmed this in a judgment concerning the…

EU General Court: classification of e-bikes imported in parts

The EU General Court considered whether separately imported e-bike components could be treated as complete e-bikes subject to anti-dumping duties. It concluded that importing individual parts separately does not, in itself, prevent such…

Constitutional Court upholds constitutional protection of legal professional…

The Constitutional Court recently confirmed that lawyer–client confidentiality shall be protected in tax proceedings as it represents a constitutional limit for the tax administrator when taking evidence.

General Court of the EU: contribution in kind to a company from a VAT perspective

In a recent judgment, the General Court of the EU considered the VAT treatment of a contribution in kind of real estate to a company whose sole shareholder is the contributor. If the contributor receives no actual consideration, the transaction does…

Case law sets boundaries for determining local real estate tax coefficients

If a municipality decides to introduce a local coefficient for specified real estate, since 1 January 2025 it has been required to do so by means of a measure of a general nature. The first wave of court disputes already sheds light on the…

Constitutional Court reiterates obligation to address new arguments in tax dispute

The Constitutional Court set aside a judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) concerning the tax deductibility of interest between related parties. According to the Constitutional Court, the SAC failed to address adequately the taxpayer’s…

SAC: stricter interpretation of conditions for residence under ‘other’ category

In its recent judgment (2 Azs 64/2024), the Supreme Administrative Court confirmed that the purpose of residence under the ‘other’ category must have a sufficiently strong, close and genuine connection to the Czech Republic. The mere fact that a…

SAC on obligation to pay VAT stated in invoice

The Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) considered whether VAT stated in an invoice must be paid even where the invoiced supply is fictitious. It confirmed that the decisive factor is not the mere statement of VAT in the invoice but the existence of…

Reserve accounts for repairs of tangible assets under SAC scrutiny

In a recent judgment, the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) commented on the conditions for the tax deductibility of provisions for repairs of tangible assets. In its decision, it followed existing case law and confirmed a strict approach to…

Supreme Administrative Court on proving right to deduct VAT on subcontracted supplies

Is an invoice and a contract enough to prove the right to deduct VAT? In its recent judgment, the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) concluded that they are not. If the tax administrator challenges the scope or nature of the services received, the…