EU General Court: business gifted in two equal shares falls outside VAT transfer rules
The transfer of a business free of charge to two individuals, each receiving a half share, does not constitute a transfer of a totality of assets or part thereof under Article 19 of the VAT Directive if neither share allows its recipient to carry on an economic activity independently. The recipients’ intention to contribute both shares to a jointly owned company did not alter the EU General Court’s conclusion.
The case concerned a businesswoman who intended to transfer her entire business to her two daughters as a gift, each receiving a half share. She would retain none of the business assets and would cease her economic activity after the transfer. Her daughters planned to contribute their shares immediately to a general partnership, which would continue the business’s original activity largely unchanged.
The EU General Court first considered whether the gift of the shares to the daughters and their subsequent contribution to the partnership could be treated as a single supply. It recalled that supplies must generally be assessed separately for VAT purposes. They may be treated as a single supply only where they are so closely linked that they objectively form a single, indivisible economic supply. In this case, each daughter could dispose of her share independently and decide whether to contribute it to the partnership. Moreover, the subsequent contribution was not a condition of the gift: it was independent of it and would take place later. The gifts of the individual shares and their subsequent contribution to the partnership therefore constituted separate supplies.
The EU General Court further recalled that Article 19 of the VAT Directive applies only where the assets being transferred, taken together, allow an independent economic activity to be carried on. Since the supplies were being assessed separately, this condition had to be met for each daughter individually. However, each received only a half share, which did not, in itself, constitute a self-contained unit capable of operating independently.
The EU General Court therefore concluded that the gift in question could not be treated as a transfer of a totality of assets or part thereof that is not regarded as a supply of goods for VAT purposes. The ultimate intention to keep the business operating is not sufficient on its own: the assets acquired by each recipient must also allow that recipient to continue the economic activity independently.