Back to article list

Disposal of goods and their subsequent use: determining correct VAT treatment

In a recent discussion paper, the Coordination Committee of the General Financial Directorate (GFD) and the Chamber of Tax Advisors addressed the VAT treatment of the disposal of goods where disposal involves recovering raw materials, spare parts or other items for subsequent sale, confirming that what matters is the substance of the transaction, rather than just the terms of the contract or the parties’ intentions.

The first question was whether the original owner of the goods being disposed of merely receives a disposal service or whether they also supply goods to the disposal company. The GFD emphasised that the economic substance of the particular transaction must be considered. If the recovered material has value for the disposal company and that value is reflected in the disposal price, there may indeed be two separate supplies involved: a disposal service and, simultaneously, a supply of goods. The value of the consideration need not be expressly agreed in the contract. What matters is whether this value was actually taken into account when setting the price of the disposal service.

Regarding the determination of the taxable amount, the GFD emphasised that, where open market value is used, it must reflect the value of the specific supply at the time it takes place. It is therefore crucial to establish what is being supplied and when. The open market value determined on this basis cannot subsequently be changed merely by agreement between the parties. Any change would have to be justified by objective circumstances affecting the value of the supply.

The discussion also addressed whether goods supplied as part of the disposal could be subject to the reverse charge mechanism. The GFD emphasised that this mechanism must be interpreted narrowly. The determining factors are the goods’ objective characteristics and their classification under the Combined Nomenclature and Annex 5 to the VAT Act. The owner’s decision to stop using an asset or hand it over for disposal is therefore not sufficient, on its own, for the goods to be treated as waste or scrap. The VAT treatment therefore depends on the nature of the goods supplied, not on how the supplier views them.

Another issue concerned the VAT treatment of sales of items recovered during disposal, such as spare parts from end-of-life vehicles. The GFD accepted that, when applying the special scheme for dealers in second-hand goods, the purchase price of an end-of-life vehicle may be reduced by the average expected proceeds from the sale of scrap. It cautioned, however, that any negative amount resulting from this calculation cannot be carried forward to subsequent taxable periods.

The Coordination Committee thus primarily confirms that the VAT treatment of the disposal of goods cannot be determined solely by the contractual arrangements or the individual parties’ intentions. What matters is the economic substance of the transaction, particularly what is actually supplied, its condition and when the supply takes place. These factors determine the number of supplies, the taxable amount and the correct VAT treatment.

If you are dealing with similar questions concerning the disposal of goods and their subsequent use or sale, we would be pleased to help you determine the correct VAT treatment.