Back to article list

EU General Court: classification of e-bikes imported in parts

The EU General Court considered whether separately imported e-bike components could be treated as complete e-bikes subject to anti-dumping duties. It concluded that importing individual parts separately does not, in itself, prevent such classification.

In January 2019, the EU introduced anti-dumping duties on imports of e-bikes from China classified under Combined Nomenclature code 8711 60 10. These measures did not, however, cover certain parts and accessories falling under code 8714.

Between 2019 and 2021, a Belgian company purchased e-bike components from two different Chinese suppliers and imported them in separate containers over several months. During an inspection, the Belgian customs authorities established that the imported components were subsequently assembled into complete e-bikes supplied to customers.

The key to determining the components’ tariff classification was a rule in the General Rules for the Interpretation of the Combined Nomenclature. Under this rule, goods may, in certain circumstances, be classified as a complete article even when presented unassembled or disassembled. The General Court therefore focused on whether the rule could also apply where individual components are imported separately, in different consignments and at different times.

The General Court concluded that importing individual parts separately does not prevent their classification as a complete article. The decisive question is whether, at the time of customs clearance, objective facts establish that the individual parts form a single whole and are intended to be assembled into one article. It is not necessary for all the parts to be presented to customs at the same time.

In this context, the General Court also addressed earlier case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. In the General Court’s view, that case law does not establish that individual parts of an article must be presented simultaneously at customs clearance, since the Court of Justice had not considered this specific question in those cases.

The General Court further held that presenting individual parts to customs under several separate customs declarations does not, in itself, prevent the components from being declared under the Combined Nomenclature code for the finished article. The opposite interpretation would allow importers to influence tariff classification merely by splitting imports across several customs declarations, enabling them to choose at will, depending on the circumstances, between classifying goods as a single whole or as individual components.

The judgment is particularly significant for companies using supply chains in which parts of a single finished article are imported separately. Correct tariff classification may therefore depend on more than the contents of a particular consignment. Objective circumstances linking the individual imports and indicating that the imported parts are intended to be assembled into a specific complete article may also be relevant.