Back to article list

CJEU: abuse of law not limited to conduit companies

A parent company’s genuine economic activity and beneficial ownership of income do not, in themselves, preclude application of the abuse of law doctrine. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) confirmed this in a judgment concerning the tax exemption of dividends under the Parent-Subsidiary Directive. It held that the assessment must consider both the overall outcome of the arrangement and the outcome of each individual transaction.

The CJEU considered the tax exemption of dividends paid by two Lithuanian companies to their Cypriot parent company. The Cypriot company had originally been owned by a Belizean company, which sold its interest to a new Cypriot holding company. The Cypriot holding company and the Belizean company were owned by the same individual. The Belizean company assigned the receivable arising from the sale to that individual. The Cypriot holding company then used dividends received from the Lithuanian companies to lend money to the individual. The debt under the loan was subsequently offset against the receivable.

The Lithuanian tax authorities took the view that there was no economic justification for the arrangement. In their view, its purpose was to pay dividends directly to the individual through a series of artificial transactions. They did not dispute that the Cypriot parent company carried out a genuine economic activity or that it was the beneficial owner of the dividends. Nevertheless, they denied the withholding tax exemption on the grounds of abuse of law.

The CJEU confirmed that the abuse of law doctrine has a broad scope and cannot be confined to conduit companies. A parent company’s genuine economic activity does not prevent the doctrine from applying, nor does beneficial ownership of the income concerned. When assessing potential abuse of law, the arrangement must be considered as a whole, including transactions carried out in other countries.
Moreover, neither the subsidiary nor the parent company has to benefit directly from the tax advantage.

An advantage obtained by the group’s ultimate owner through the chain of transactions may also be taken into account. The tax authorities do not have to prove that the subsidiary paying the dividends knew or could have known that the dividend payment formed part of a transaction or series of transactions constituting an abuse of law. It is sufficient to establish such knowledge on the part of at least one company involved in the chain or the individual who ultimately obtained the tax advantage.

The judgment thus confirms that a parent company’s genuine economic activity and beneficial ownership of the income concerned do not, in themselves, preclude application of the abuse of law doctrine.