Back to article list

EU General Court: boat repairs in EU need not incur duty or import VAT

Where goods from a third country are brought into the EU solely for repair and then returned without being used there, import VAT may not arise and any customs debt may be extinguished. The EU General Court confirmed this in a judgment addressing both VAT and the interpretation of the Union Customs Code.

The case concerned a Swiss resident who transported his Swiss-registered sailing boat to Germany on a trailer but failed to present it to customs at the border. During a customs inspection, he explained that he was taking it to a German company for maintenance and repairs. Once the work was completed, he took the boat back to Switzerland without having sailed it in the EU.

The customs authorities assessed both customs duty and import VAT. They took the view that the repairs had brought the boat into the EU’s economic network and that its subsequent export had not extinguished the customs debt. The owner argued that the boat had merely undergone maintenance and had not been used in the EU. Germany’s Federal Fiscal Court therefore referred questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union, which transferred them to the General Court. The General Court has had jurisdiction to give preliminary rulings on VAT and customs matters only since October 2024, and this judgment is among its first to interpret the Union Customs Code.

In Case T-383/25, Segelbootwartung, the General Court confirmed that failure to comply with customs obligations gives rise only to a presumption that the goods have entered the EU’s economic network and are therefore subject to import VAT. This presumption can be rebutted if the importer proves that the goods were not intended for use in the EU and left it without actually being used there. For means of transport, particular consideration is given to the owner’s place of residence, where they are normally used and how long they remained in the EU. According to the General Court, actual use means using an item for its intended purpose – in the case of a sailing boat, sailing it. Neither transporting it to a workshop nor repairing it constitutes use. The repair services may themselves be subject to VAT, but they are a separate supply and have no bearing on import VAT on the boat.

The General Court took a similar approach to customs duty. Although the failure to comply with customs obligations had created a customs debt, that debt may subsequently be extinguished under the conditions laid down in the Union Customs Code if the goods were not used in the EU and were re-exported. Repairs cannot be regarded as use if they could have been authorised under the inward processing procedure, which specifically allows goods from third countries to be repaired or processed without payment of customs duty. According to the General Court, the absence of an authorisation does not automatically rule out extinguishment of the customs debt. The decisive question is whether the work could have been authorised under inward processing, including retrospectively. The German court will now assess this.

The judgment is particularly welcome for businesses servicing and repairing boats, aircraft, vehicles or machinery and having customers from third countries. It is not, however, a guide to avoiding customs formalities. Anyone who fails to present goods to customs risks being assessed for customs duty and VAT, as well as facing penalties. They must provide objective, verifiable evidence that the goods were neither intended for use in the EU nor actually used there. Above all, the judgment is a reminder that goods brought in for repair should always be properly declared and placed under the inward processing procedure.