Disguised employment mediation could become a criminal offence
Disguised employment mediation has long been among the most common breaches of labour law identified by labour inspectors. A little-noticed amending proposal to the Criminal Code bill currently before the Chamber of Deputies aims to significantly tighten the penalties for this practice: it could become a criminal offence punishable by up to eight years’ imprisonment.
Disguised employment mediation is an illegal practice whereby a supplier formally provides a service or carries out work for a customer, but in reality merely supplies workers who operate under the customer’s instructions and supervision, effectively as the customer’s employees. However, only a duly licensed employment agency may legally supply workers in this way.
This practice is currently an administrative offence carrying substantial penalties – a fine of up to CZK 10 million for each party or a ban on activities. These penalties are now set to become even stricter.
What the amendment proposes
The amending proposal under consideration introduces criminal liability for circumventing the rules on agency employment: it stipulates a basic sentence of three years’ imprisonment, which may rise to eight years in the most serious cases. Both parties to the illegal contractual arrangement could face these penalties: the supplier of workers (the ‘pseudo-agency’) and the customer.
Making disguised employment mediation a criminal offence is a significant development, particularly because this is neither a marginal nor an isolated problem. On the contrary, it regularly features in decisions by labour inspectors and administrative courts. Many employers are not even aware that they themselves are breaking the law by working with pseudo-agencies.
The boundary between lawful outsourcing and illegal practices is not clearly defined in legislation and is not always straightforward. The Supreme Administrative Court has consistently emphasised that there is no single dividing line – each case must be assessed individually. What matters is not the title of the contract or the formal description of the arrangement, but how it actually operates. This is also reflected in the approach taken by labour inspectors: inspections go beyond the wording of the contract to focus on day-to-day reality in the workplace.
Practical implications
Although the sudden proposal to make disguised employment mediation a criminal offence is surprising, it clearly follows earlier steps by the state to tighten the penalties for this practice. Companies using outsourcing arrangements should take note and focus not only on reviewing their contractual documentation but also on assessing how the arrangements operate in practice from day to day. Even well-drafted contracts cannot eliminate the risk if the arrangement in fact amounts to supplying workers rather than providing a service or carrying out contracted work.
Auditing supplier arrangements and their timely legal review is generally much simpler and less costly than dealing with the findings of an inspection by the authorities afterwards – particularly as criminal law enforcement authorities could now become involved.